01What does AI actually do in company reports?

All three can help with the same work: tidying data from Excel or CSV, summarizing month-to-month changes, writing draft report narrative, and answering questions about the contents of a file. All three also share the same limits: AI can misread a column, add up wrongly, or write a conclusion the data does not support. So compare how well each tool fits the way your team works, not simply which one is the smartest.

Try it yourself

Scoreboard: which AI tool fits your team?

Fill it in after you test all three with your own files. Importance runs from 1 to 3, scores from 1 to 5. Everything starts neutral at 3.

CriterionImportanceClaudeChatGPTGemini
Data terms and security
Ability to read your files
Quality in Bahasa Indonesia
Fit with the team's apps
Cost per user
Claude
ChatGPT
Gemini

The scores come from your own testing, not from Mandalab's assessment of any product.

Ask for help preparing the test

02What criteria should you use to choose?

  1. Data terms. Read each service's data-use terms and business plan yourself: is your data used to train models, where is it stored, and who can access it. Consumer plans and business plans generally differ.
  2. Ability to read your files. Test with a real ERP export file, including a messy one, not a tidy sample.
  3. Quality of Bahasa Indonesia. Ask it to write a report paragraph and read it as a business owner would: does it sound natural, or like a translation?
  4. Fit with your team's apps. If the team works in Google Workspace or Microsoft 365, look at the options integrated with the documents and email there.
  5. Cost per user and usage limits. Count how many people will really use it every day, and check the official pricing page because plans change often.

03How do you test them fairly?

Use the same procedure for all three:

  1. Prepare one month's sales export file whose results you already know.
  2. Ask five identical questions, for example "which customer's revenue dropped the most compared with last month" (include the data for both months) and "what is the total sales of product A in cartons".
  3. Compare the answers with your own calculation. Note how many are right, how many are wrong, and how many cannot be traced to a source.
  4. Ask for a draft report paragraph in Bahasa Indonesia, then read whether the language sounds natural.
  5. Repeat with slightly different questions to check consistency.

Anonymize the data or use data you have permission to upload, especially if the file contains customer names or prices covered by a confidentiality agreement.

04Which suits which type of team?

Use this picture to decide which tool to try first. The final choice should still rest on your test results:

  • Teams that use Google Workspace every day usually try Gemini first because it connects with Docs, Sheets and Gmail.
  • Teams that use Microsoft 365 every day usually look at the AI options within that ecosystem first.
  • Teams that work with long documents and file analysis should test Claude and ChatGPT side by side with their own files.

Results in your company may differ, and each service's features keep changing, so retest every few months.

05Is one tool enough?

Many companies start with one tool for one workflow, then add more if needed. Measure success by the working time saved and the corrections still needed, not by the number of tools subscribed to. The working rules matter more than the brand: who checks, what data may be uploaded, and which figures must always be matched to the official report.

FAQ

Is it safe to put sales data into Claude, ChatGPT or Gemini?

Safety depends on the plan and terms you choose. Read the data terms of the business plan, avoid uploading NDA-bound data without permission, and reduce personal data that is not needed. Law No. 27 of 2022 on Personal Data Protection applies to personal data your company handles.

Can AI output go straight into a report for a bank or client?

Match every figure to the official source, then have someone who understands the data check the conclusions before the report is sent. AI speeds up the draft; responsibility for the content stays with the company.

Which one is cheapest?

Prices change and depend on the plan and number of users, so check each service's official pricing page and calculate for your number of users. Compare the subscription cost with the working hours your team can save on your own tasks.

Can AI read large Excel files from an ERP?

Capability differs between services and plans, and depends on the size and tidiness of the file. Test with your own file and, if it is too large, clean and condense it before uploading.

AIReports